X close icon
Hate your payroll process?
Run payroll in 1 minute with Onfolk’s modern automated software.
Book demo

How Much Does Payroll Software Cost vs Outsourcing Payroll?

Table of contents

Can I do my own payroll UK? Outsourcing payroll vs. using software in-house

When it comes to managing payroll for your small business in the UK, you have two main options: outsourcing or using payroll software in-house. Each approach has its own advantages and considerations.

Outsourcing payroll involves hiring a third-party provider to handle all aspects of your payroll processing, from calculating wages to submitting tax returns. This can save you time and ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, as payroll experts take care of all the necessary paperwork. However, it is essential to consider the cost implications of outsourcing. While it frees up your time to focus on core business activities, it often comes with a higher price tag.

On the other hand, using payroll software in-house allows you to retain control over your payroll processes. With a variety of HR and payroll software solutions available, you can find a system that meets the specific needs of your small business. By taking advantage of features like automated calculations and real-time reporting, you can streamline your payroll operations and reduce the risk of errors. However, it is important to evaluate your business needs and budget before choosing this option.

Evaluating your business needs and budget

Before deciding between outsourcing and using payroll software in-house, you need to evaluate your business needs and budget. Consider factors such as the size of your workforce, the complexity of your payroll requirements, and the level of control you desire over the process.

If you have a small number of employees and straightforward payroll calculations, using payroll software in-house may be a cost-effective solution. However, if you have a larger workforce or complex payroll requirements, outsourcing payroll to a dedicated provider may be more efficient. Additionally, consider your budgetary constraints and the long-term costs associated with each option. While payroll software may require an upfront investment, outsourcing can involve ongoing service fees.

Different types of payroll software available for small businesses

When it comes to choosing payroll software for your small business, there are several options available in the UK market. These software solutions cater specifically to the needs of small businesses, offering a range of features to simplify payroll management. Here are some popular payroll software options:

  1. Accounting software (eg. Xero or QuickBooks): on top of bookkeeping, accounting software will often offer an add-on feature to enable you to run payroll on your own through their platform. This is typically payroll software for accountants. Compare Onfolk vs Xero
  2. Free payroll software (eg. 12Cloud payroll): some payroll softwares may offer a freemium model whereby you can benefit from their free tier and submit payroll figures to HMRC every month.
  3. Paid-for, payroll-only software (eg. Pento): traditional payroll softwares and more modern payroll products are available on the UK market today, specialising in different types of business (small, medium, enterprise). They’ll offer more powerful payroll features than free payroll and accounting softwares, such as holistic a payroll dashboard.
  4. Integrated payroll and HRIS system (eg. Onfolk): similar to payroll-only software, HR and payroll software products specialise in offering an all-in-one hr and payroll software experience to business owners to save them time on admin.

Running Payroll in the UK: How Onfolk Compares to Other Payroll Methods

Understanding payroll automation and its impact on cost

Payroll automation is a key feature of modern payroll software, and it can have a significant impact on the overall cost of managing your payroll. By automating repetitive tasks and streamlining processes, payroll software can reduce the time and effort required to complete payroll-related activities.

Automated calculations eliminate the need for manual computations, reducing the risk of errors and saving valuable time. Real-time reporting provides instant access to payroll data, allowing you to make informed decisions and identify potential cost-saving opportunities. Additionally, automation helps ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, minimizing the risk of penalties and fines.

6 Best Payroll Software and HR Tools for Startups in 2023

Pricing models for payroll software providers

Different payroll software providers may offer varying pricing models, so it is essential to understand how they charge for their services. Here are some common pricing models for payroll software:

  1. Subscription-based: Many payroll software providers offer a subscription-based pricing model, where you pay a monthly or annual fee for access to their software. This fee may vary depending on the number of employees you have.
  2. Per payslip: Some providers charge based on the number of payslips you generate each pay period. This can be beneficial if you have a small number of employees and want to pay only for what you use.
  3. One-time purchase: Certain payroll software solutions require a one-time purchase, which includes lifetime access to the software. This can be a cost-effective option if you have a stable workforce without significant fluctuations.

When calculating the cost of payroll software for your small business, several factors come into play. Here are some key factors that can affect the overall cost:

  • Number of employees: If your payroll software provider charges based on the number of employees you have, as your workforce grows, the cost of the software will increase accordingly.
  • Additional features: Some payroll software solutions offer additional features beyond basic payroll processing. These features may come at an additional cost, so consider whether they are necessary for your business.
  • Support and training: If you require extensive support or training from the software provider, it may incur additional costs. Evaluate the level of support you need and whether it is included in the base price or requires an additional fee.

Calculating the cost of payroll outsourcing

If you decide to outsource your payroll, calculating the cost involves considering several factors. Here are some key elements to consider when determining the cost of payroll outsourcing:

  1. Service fees: Payroll providers typically charge a service fee based on the number of employees and the complexity of your payroll requirements. Request quotes from different providers to compare their pricing structures.
  2. Additional services: Some payroll providers offer additional services, such as tax form filing and employee self-service portals. These services may come at an extra cost, so evaluate whether they are essential for your business.
  3. Compliance and penalties: Outsourcing payroll can help ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, reducing the risk of penalties and fines. Consider the potential cost savings associated with avoiding compliance-related issues.

Outsourcing vs payroll software cost: the numbers

Below is a table of payroll service costs for each method of payroll processing.

We’ve taken a few companies as pricing examples. You’ll notice that not all payroll software providers have the same pricing model. Some will count their payroll cost per employee, others will include a subscription flat fee. However, this should give you a good indication of what kind of price point you may be looking at based on your company’s needs and size. This is the case for Xero’s payroll cost model - although Xero pricing may vary based on the number of add-ons you include in your subscription. Also note that for payroll outsourcing costs, this will depend from one provider to another.

In conclusion, calculating the true cost of payroll in the UK requires a thorough evaluation of your business needs, budget, and available options. Whether you choose to outsource payroll or use payroll software in-house, it is essential to consider factors such as scalability, integration, and support. Understanding the impact of payroll automation and the various pricing models for payroll software providers can help you make an informed decision. By carefully evaluating the cost of payroll services and considering factors that affect the cost of payroll software, you can determine the most cost-effective solution for your small business.

Are you looking for the best HR and payroll tool to implement for your business? Get in touch with us.

Can I do my own payroll UK? Outsourcing payroll vs. using software in-house

When it comes to managing payroll for your small business in the UK, you have two main options: outsourcing or using payroll software in-house. Each approach has its own advantages and considerations.

Outsourcing payroll involves hiring a third-party provider to handle all aspects of your payroll processing, from calculating wages to submitting tax returns. This can save you time and ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, as payroll experts take care of all the necessary paperwork. However, it is essential to consider the cost implications of outsourcing. While it frees up your time to focus on core business activities, it often comes with a higher price tag.

On the other hand, using payroll software in-house allows you to retain control over your payroll processes. With a variety of HR and payroll software solutions available, you can find a system that meets the specific needs of your small business. By taking advantage of features like automated calculations and real-time reporting, you can streamline your payroll operations and reduce the risk of errors. However, it is important to evaluate your business needs and budget before choosing this option.

Evaluating your business needs and budget

Before deciding between outsourcing and using payroll software in-house, you need to evaluate your business needs and budget. Consider factors such as the size of your workforce, the complexity of your payroll requirements, and the level of control you desire over the process.

If you have a small number of employees and straightforward payroll calculations, using payroll software in-house may be a cost-effective solution. However, if you have a larger workforce or complex payroll requirements, outsourcing payroll to a dedicated provider may be more efficient. Additionally, consider your budgetary constraints and the long-term costs associated with each option. While payroll software may require an upfront investment, outsourcing can involve ongoing service fees.

Different types of payroll software available for small businesses

When it comes to choosing payroll software for your small business, there are several options available in the UK market. These software solutions cater specifically to the needs of small businesses, offering a range of features to simplify payroll management. Here are some popular payroll software options:

  1. Accounting software (eg. Xero or QuickBooks): on top of bookkeeping, accounting software will often offer an add-on feature to enable you to run payroll on your own through their platform. This is typically payroll software for accountants. Compare Onfolk vs Xero
  2. Free payroll software (eg. 12Cloud payroll): some payroll softwares may offer a freemium model whereby you can benefit from their free tier and submit payroll figures to HMRC every month.
  3. Paid-for, payroll-only software (eg. Pento): traditional payroll softwares and more modern payroll products are available on the UK market today, specialising in different types of business (small, medium, enterprise). They’ll offer more powerful payroll features than free payroll and accounting softwares, such as holistic a payroll dashboard.
  4. Integrated payroll and HRIS system (eg. Onfolk): similar to payroll-only software, HR and payroll software products specialise in offering an all-in-one hr and payroll software experience to business owners to save them time on admin.

Running Payroll in the UK: How Onfolk Compares to Other Payroll Methods

Understanding payroll automation and its impact on cost

Payroll automation is a key feature of modern payroll software, and it can have a significant impact on the overall cost of managing your payroll. By automating repetitive tasks and streamlining processes, payroll software can reduce the time and effort required to complete payroll-related activities.

Automated calculations eliminate the need for manual computations, reducing the risk of errors and saving valuable time. Real-time reporting provides instant access to payroll data, allowing you to make informed decisions and identify potential cost-saving opportunities. Additionally, automation helps ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, minimizing the risk of penalties and fines.

6 Best Payroll Software and HR Tools for Startups in 2023

Pricing models for payroll software providers

Different payroll software providers may offer varying pricing models, so it is essential to understand how they charge for their services. Here are some common pricing models for payroll software:

  1. Subscription-based: Many payroll software providers offer a subscription-based pricing model, where you pay a monthly or annual fee for access to their software. This fee may vary depending on the number of employees you have.
  2. Per payslip: Some providers charge based on the number of payslips you generate each pay period. This can be beneficial if you have a small number of employees and want to pay only for what you use.
  3. One-time purchase: Certain payroll software solutions require a one-time purchase, which includes lifetime access to the software. This can be a cost-effective option if you have a stable workforce without significant fluctuations.

When calculating the cost of payroll software for your small business, several factors come into play. Here are some key factors that can affect the overall cost:

  • Number of employees: If your payroll software provider charges based on the number of employees you have, as your workforce grows, the cost of the software will increase accordingly.
  • Additional features: Some payroll software solutions offer additional features beyond basic payroll processing. These features may come at an additional cost, so consider whether they are necessary for your business.
  • Support and training: If you require extensive support or training from the software provider, it may incur additional costs. Evaluate the level of support you need and whether it is included in the base price or requires an additional fee.

Calculating the cost of payroll outsourcing

If you decide to outsource your payroll, calculating the cost involves considering several factors. Here are some key elements to consider when determining the cost of payroll outsourcing:

  1. Service fees: Payroll providers typically charge a service fee based on the number of employees and the complexity of your payroll requirements. Request quotes from different providers to compare their pricing structures.
  2. Additional services: Some payroll providers offer additional services, such as tax form filing and employee self-service portals. These services may come at an extra cost, so evaluate whether they are essential for your business.
  3. Compliance and penalties: Outsourcing payroll can help ensure compliance with HMRC regulations, reducing the risk of penalties and fines. Consider the potential cost savings associated with avoiding compliance-related issues.

Outsourcing vs payroll software cost: the numbers

Below is a table of payroll service costs for each method of payroll processing.

We’ve taken a few companies as pricing examples. You’ll notice that not all payroll software providers have the same pricing model. Some will count their payroll cost per employee, others will include a subscription flat fee. However, this should give you a good indication of what kind of price point you may be looking at based on your company’s needs and size. This is the case for Xero’s payroll cost model - although Xero pricing may vary based on the number of add-ons you include in your subscription. Also note that for payroll outsourcing costs, this will depend from one provider to another.

In conclusion, calculating the true cost of payroll in the UK requires a thorough evaluation of your business needs, budget, and available options. Whether you choose to outsource payroll or use payroll software in-house, it is essential to consider factors such as scalability, integration, and support. Understanding the impact of payroll automation and the various pricing models for payroll software providers can help you make an informed decision. By carefully evaluating the cost of payroll services and considering factors that affect the cost of payroll software, you can determine the most cost-effective solution for your small business.

Are you looking for the best HR and payroll tool to implement for your business? Get in touch with us.

Share post
Copy link
https://www.onfolk.com/blog/how-much-does-payroll-software-cost-vs-outsourcing-payroll